Non-dairy chocolate milkshake. choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Creamy vegan vanilla milkshake with choices of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Crème brûlée milkshake: blended with choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Cinnamon-infused milkshake with optional whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Razz & Blue Milkshake: Blend of raspberry and blueberry. Choose from whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Vanilla bean milkshake with choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Strawberry shake with options for whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Peanut butter shake with choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Goat cheese and apricots milkshake, candied walnuts topping. Choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Mint & chocolate flakes milkshake. Choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Thou mayest coffee shake: choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Lavender honey milkshake: infused with real lavender, sweetened with honey. Options for whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
S'mores milkshake with marshmallows, chocolate syrup, and graham crackers. Milk options: whole or oat. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Matcha shake blended with choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Rich chocolate brownie milkshake. options include whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Cookies and cream milkshake: blended with crushed cookies. options include whole or oat milk and three sizes: small, medium, or large.
Cookie dough shake with options for whole or oat milk. available in small (12 oz), medium (16 oz), or large (20 oz).
Brown butter & toasted pecan milkshake, with whole or oat milk options. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Cereal-infused milkshake with choices of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Rich chocolate shake with choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
Matcha-flavored ice cream. available sizes: pint, quart, gallon.
As a reviewer, I found Betty Rae's Ice Cream menu to be a creative and satisfying showcase of classic favorites and inventive flavors. The shake selection stands out with options like Non-Dairy Chocolate, Vegan Vanilla, Crème Brûlée Cinnamon, and Razz & Blue, offering something for both traditional ice cream lovers and those seeking dairy-free alternatives. The ice cream menu is equally impressive, featuring rich and distinctive choices such as Crème Brûlée, Cereal And Milk, Goat Cheese With Apricots And Candied Walnuts, Brown Butter & Toasted Pecans, and the timeless Vanilla Bean. Each flavor brings its own personality, ranging from nostalgic and comforting to bold and gourmet. The variety reflects a thoughtful approach to ingredients and flavor combinations, making it easy to sample something familiar or venture into a more adventurous treat. Overall, the menu feels well-balanced, with enough diversity to appeal to a wide range of tastes while maintaining the high-quality, handcrafted character that makes an ice cream shop memorable.